I'm tubing-mascara-monogamous as well it brought me back to mascara after years of not wearing due to hassles with removal, and smearing my glasses. (Sounds like MrsEccentric had the same epiphany, no?)
I've only tried Blinc and Becca so far. I prefer the Blinc because it stayed on better than the Becca (which occasionally would come off a lash or two - in a tube of course). I also found the Becca looked a bit dramatic for my tastes.
I did get the Blinc in a mini/sample size (which lasted me ages!) and when I get another I will have to see if I prefer the full size brush or the mini brush.
I agree with Maya that YMMV - I have long, curly lashes and just need a bit of emphasis. I suggest you read reviews on Makeupalley.com to see how different people find it.
Blinc is waterproof in cold water; that is, it needs a COMBINATION of *warm* water and pressure to come off (I put my face under a running tap and very gently rub my eyes; you see the little tubes going down the sink and it's cool! Or do the same in the shower, couldn't be easier, no special eye makeup remover needed).
Plenty of reviewers say they cried in tubing mascara and it didn't come off. Each brand is slightly different and your preference will depend on both the formula and the brush as well as the effect you require. Blinc is said to be the original and the most truly "tubing" (that is, it really stays on while you want it to, and it really does come off effortlessly with warm water and pressure).
