The first thing I noticed was your hair in #3 and also the same thing is happening a little in #4. It's the way your hair looks a little longer, your bangs are falling a little longer. It looks so soft and pretty. Your skin looks great in this #3 too. Maybe it's the top? So that is my favorite for overall fabness, #3, and how could I also not be thrilled to see my name referenced? You are using my favorite bag, your straw tote which is so on-trend.
But I also really love #1, it's very J Crew, a website I look at all the time for inspiration.