I really like the first one and the last one. I don't see any lumps and bumps, but the pictures are far away. I know I see them on myself sometime even when others don't. The middle two seem too long and not as flattering. If you are having a muffin top issue maybe you should look into new jeans. Do you have any that are maybe not as tight around the waist? How do those shirts look with them? Maybe some nice shape wear is an option? Spanx are great for smoothing you out a bit.

It was not essy for me to see the detail in the darker tops. I thought you did look especially nice in the lighter color of the hoodie.

I like the first black one, and the purple one. The 2 in the middle aren't as flattering- send those back.l

I honestly am not seeing any muffin top (the correct rise on your jeans help with that btw). I also find that wearing a stretchy cami with a little bit of spandex can help alot if you feel self conscious wearing more fitted tops. Like Queenie, I also like the first top as well as your purple hoodie. The first black top is so so and might work with the right bottom.

Thanks for the thoughts! I have placed another order at VS, getting my two faves (the first and last tops in the pics) in a bigger size. Maybe that would help? They just seem so tight at the arms, too... You can't really tell in the pic, but my arms look like stuffed sausages in these shirts...

The first top is sensational! I love the colour of the last top too, even though I’m not fond of the hood on such a casual garment after a certain age. I hope that helps.