Thank you for responding. Right now it's still in the 90's so I have time to contemplate. I think the two vests show the style extremes that I am drawn to. I was ready to order the JCrew when I saw Angie's post and realized how different it was than the trends she showed.
Joy: I probably should order both and actually try them on. Good suggestion.
Angie: I thought you would choose Faux fur and I can see this one working with black - dark and romantic?
Firecracker: They are very different styles. I've been wearing long and drapey so either one is a big step out of my comfort zone. Maybe I should look for something more boho. I'm trying to be more thoughtful in my purchases and this is a good example of the trouble I have in making decisions.
Tanya: In the past, I would have never considered the faux fur but have been trying to figure out how to add the maximal trend to my wardrobe. I think that this faux fur would work with black to add a maximal look.
Arizaphale: You made me laugh. Thank you!
JAileen: You're right. Maybe I need a third option, a fantastic boho vest that goes everywhere.
peacechick: I really like the first vest too, but it is not maximal. But if the maximal trend lasts five years, I will get a lot of wear out of the faux fur.
Mirjana: I've never had fur or faux fur, so this might be a good first step.
El Cee: If I hadn't spent all of my budgeted allowance this month, I probably would order both and maybe another style that is both sporty and trendy, if something like that exists. I'd like to dip in to the maximal style and thought a vest would be a good way.