I asked about the colour because this one is quite different from the other colours you were looking at. To me a reddish brown is an obvious tonal fit with burgundy and aubergine (and the other colours we both wear). A yellowish brown creates more of a contrast and it wasn't as obvious to me how well it would work with all of "our" colours. So I would want to play around with it first. I did not mean to be negative, just particular! The jacket looks great. If I had the budget for a closet full of leather jackets I would take one in every shade of brown (including this one) thank you very much.

Good idea, Suz. I'll do a comparison post in the same lighting, as I haven't returned the moto yet.

Brooklyn, I did appreciate your comment, and didn't take it as overly critical at all. I think I'm just feeling worn down, because I've returned fourteen items over the past two weeks and kept two.

Perhaps show hubs the other moto in person. He might change his mind. I REALLY like the idea of doing the comparison - thanks, Jenn.

Angie, he did see the moto in person. Hasn't seen the Wilson scuba yet.

How weird is it that pretty much every jacket I've tried has been listed as "cognac"? The colors are all over the place!

Blast. I was holding out hope.

This one is my favorite so far. My only concern is the fit through the shoulders, which I didn't notice until JAileen mentioned it. I'm not sure if a different size would help that. Overall, though, I find it quite flattering on you.

I haven't read the above comments carefully, but I think there was some discussion about the color being neutral or warm or cool. I was always taught that brown was a neutral, but in practice, I have found that browns can be cool or warm and act as a bona fide color for me (others' experiences may be different). So if you decide to keep this jacket, I would definitely try it out with some of your favorite outfits and see how it works color-wise.

I know this is frustrating. I have been looking for a leather jacket for two years myself but haven't found anything. I'm determined not to settle. So if you end up not keeping this, know that you're not the only one in the leather jacket desert.

Here are both jackets I still have, side-by-side, along with a photo showing the leather colors together in natural light. Vastly different. Both were labeled "cognac," but I kind of feel like neither actually is.

#1 - Left is Guess moto. Right is Wilsons scuba.

#2 - Color comparison

#3 - Another option if I decide to keep looking, though it's a new-to-me brand, so no idea if sizing/quality would work out.

What do you think? Left, right, or keep looking?

(BTW, Angie, I had husband look again and he says he likes "color on the left, fit on the right," which, really, is no help at all.)

They are very different colours, but I'd second Gigi's advice to try the new jacket with your preferred outfits and see if you like the resulting colour combos. If you love this jacket and can't wait to wear it, never mind about possible not-perfect-fit issues.

I'm not fussed about the color working with my wardrobe. I have a closet full of neutrals, with a couple of burgundy pieces. Most of the color I do own is in my toppers. (Hmm, that feels like a revelation. Will have to ponder what that means for my closet.)

Now seeing them side by side, I think that the Guess Moto has a better fit looking from the front view. But it sounds as if you were not fond of the deeper color. Perhaps continuing to look would not be a bad idea. Buying a good leather jacket is an investment and worth the time spent to find the perfect one.

I like them both Jenn and see them as fitting well. I think leather jackets do mould to their owner after time anyway....

I think it comes down to what you like (with a nod to your partner).....

Now that I see them side by side, I much prefer the one on the left for you. Both color and style. That new Find looks like it has great potential. I like the more rugged feel of it, the quilted elbows for some moto styling, and it has the scuba style that seems to be working better for you.
Your DH's response is helpful, in that it suggests a continued search may be the answer.

What is it about the fit on the Guess jacket that isn't working? I thought the main issue was the color on that one--more brown than cognac. But It just looks so good with your hair, with your darker colors. . . its gorgeousness on you really stands out to me next to the Wilson one. Whatever your DH is responding to, he is seeing you in real life, though, and we are just seeing photos.

Firecracker, I think it's that I'm pear-shaped and the Guess moto makes that triangle shape that mirrors the inverted triangle of my bottom half, so I end up looking diamond- rather than hourglass-shaped. I'd love a jacket that nips in a bit at the waist to mitigate that effect, but most of the ones I've tried don't flare back out enough to accommodate my hips.

I think I prefer the fit of the second, lighter one. The arms are a little shorter and there is a straight line in the front that is a little more flattering, to my eye.

I vote keep looking. The lighter jacket does not have enough coverage in the front, Jenn.

I prefer the contrast of the lighter color with your hair if you often wear it down.

I agree with Sally, that it comes down to what you like. They both look good. I can see what you mean about the second one being a more flattering shape. I like the third option too, if you have the fortitude to continue the search.

Thanks, everyone, for your continued patience and help! I don't think I'd ever be 100% happy with either of these, so onward! I've ordered the next one on the list. I keep reminding myself of what Smittie said earlier, it's still just the start of the season!

Jenn -- It sounds as if you have a preference for the slimmer scuba style fit over the moto option in terms of figure flattery. Is it possible to try the Wilson's scuba jacket in a size up? This might resolve what Angie terms the "front coverage" issue, although the back fit might not be as good if you did that. Hard to know without a try-on. The new option you posted might fit the bill as it is the scuba cut.

Jenn, I just know you are going to find the right one. Don't they say persistence is the key to success?

Thanks, Muffin. They do say that, but I'll admit, I'd rather be flexing my persistence muscle on something other than just finding a jacket.

El Cee, I thought about trying the size up, but I suspect it would fit sloppily, and since hubs doesn't like the color, it didn't seem worth it.

Then you are right to move along with your search. I so admire your patience and persistence. It will surely pay off when you find your perfect cognac leather jacket. The new one you are ordering is interesting. I love the shoulder and elbow stitching. Keeping fingers crossed for you.

Next and onward!