I think metallics are considered neutrals if they are somewhat muted.Those are really adorable shoes. I may be the wrong person to ask because I tend to like colorful shoes especially flats(which I think can look too "sensible" in all neutral colors like black and brown).It will depend on your wardrobe and how often you really will wear those fuscia shoes. They will go with alot of colors esp if you have a wardrobe with neutrals like denim,brown,grey etc.And if they make you smile when you put them on, keep them :-)
If they make you frown or worry, take them back.

The pewter is a neutral for sure - I think you will find that flat very versatile.
Fuschia is very bold but if they are comfy and you are creative, you can pair with so many things. I like a bright pop of color shoe myself.

Hurray for finding comfy and stylish shoes!

I loved those shoes when I saw them. I like both but pewter is definitely a neutral. Fuschia isn't a neutral but I'm sure it can work just as well depending how comfortable you are with color mixing. I'm pretty bold with color choices and I think it's much more rare and difficult to find two colors that DON'T work together than two colors that do.

I loved those shoes but I did not even try them on because I am NOT buying any more suede shoes in Chicago!

Kristen, why? Because of salt stains? I'm still a newbie/temporary Chicagoan (originally from California).

OOOH, I'm after silver or pewter flats! Could someone please describe these? Where's the bow, and what do they mean when they say it's "zipper-trimmed?"

Kristen, are they all suede? The pewter seems to be in leather.

Michelle, they are SO cute and perfect for our wide feet! The colored ones are suede but the pewter is leather. It's a simple soft ballet flat with a bow embellishment on the top towards the toe. The leather bow is "outlined" with a zipper trim... so the actual bow has an edgy zipper around it. The zipper isn't chunky, it's just enough to give the feminine shoes something special. On the pewter the zipper trim is in a gold/bronze color.

Yes, MC, between the snow, salt and rain, I found that suede shoes have about a two-day window of opportunity to be worn without getting destroyed by the elements. So this year I am determined not to buy any even though there are so many adorable ones!

The pewters are cute, and being leather certainly gets my thumbs up. :)

Thanks, Marianna, you give great descriptions too! They do sound pretty cute, I must say.
I'd be interested in Angie's take on the pewters, since she doesn't approve of mixing metallics? Does it work here, and if so why?

I'd love to hear Angie's opinion too. I hope I'm not way off on this one!

MariannaCecile, Those are lovely. Do you think they would fit a wide foot?

Yes, very good fit for a wide foot! My foot is wide and the width is perfect.

MC, what size do you wear? I was told that the pewter were sold out company-wide. These are cute flats. I even managed to get a good fit with my narrow feet. That's sayin' somethin'...

I like both colors! I think the pewter is more versatile, and the fuschia adds a great unexpected pop of color. I guess it depends on your wardrobe and what you want the shoe to do, stylewise. Although, it might be a moot point because of the suede vs leather issue!

lwc - I wear size 12. They didn't have my size in store but the sales associate located it at another store and it is being shipped. Maybe I got lucky that my oddball size was available? I see that only size 4 and 4.5 are left online...

Beautiful flats! I was quite tempted by them myself (but resisted.) I'm a big fan of fuchsia and think they go with a lot of things, but if you are looking for a truly neutral shoe then I'd go with the pewter. Those you can definitely wear with EVERYTHING. I think it depends on what other shoes you already have in your closet.

I loved this flat too. I resisted because I have plenty of ballet flats and boot season is lurking. I’d go for the metallic.