I like the buckle boots. I think they could work with skirts/dresses.

In terms of fit, the mia moto ones look too big at the back of the calf and there seems to be a small gap at the front of the gee wawa ones. I think they'd work with jeans tucked in but i'm a bit unsure about skirts and dresses? x

Angie,
Do either get approval- have you heard of the brand gee wawa?

The gee wawa buckle boots get my vote. I like the fit, height and details better than the other pair. The mia motos remind me of rain boots. Can they be scrunched down?

I like the gee wawa better. love the buckle detail and the heighth.

I really like the Gee Wawa buckle boots, in terms of the length and the fit. I would love to know how that name came about!

another vote for Gee Wawa boots, I prefer the slghtly longer length of them. I had never heard of the brand before today.

Never heard of Gee Wawa?? Funny name! The Gee Wawas are a less refined and more boho, which might be what you're after, in which case they are great. About the gaping around the calf on the second boot, I don't think it matters as they are not meant to be fitted boots.

Is one pair more comfy than the other?

I like the taller ones on you, but that's my personal bias. I think women with long legs like you and I have just look better in knee-height rather than calf.

I think the gee wawas are the most popular, are they a 10? Boots are my biggest splurge, I need many styles. I want these to be unique and work with girly dresses and tops.
Should I keep looking???

Not sure on the boots, but I love your tights.

Hands down the longer pair. They are FABULOUS!