Thanks everyone for the honest opinions!
You're right Angie, I really wanted this jacket to be perfect, but unfortunately it's not. It's good to know that I can trust my instinct though: I knew it wasn't right from the moment I saw myself in the dressing room mirror. It didn't scream out KILLER, and that's what it should have done;-)
And it's ever so sweet of you to have tried on your own jackets again to help out!
And you're all right: the colour's perfect (exactly San, that's what appealed to me immediately) but I shouldn't (and I don't want to either) settle for something I don't feel completely at ease in and that has the perfect fit for me, so it's going back!
Tanya & Shiny: I realise that it's supposed to be cropped and a bit blousy in the back, and somebody else will probably look smashing in it, but being tall I would prefer it just a little bit longer.
Jillian & Shell: thanks for the compliments on the jeans;-)
Nicole & Dani: the turned-up collar did make me feel very sassy, I like the look on me (something to remember for the future;-)
Grin, Patience, our search continues!