I also like everything that I cook. (Why would I cook anything I didn't like?:)) Obviously I'm only cooking for myself and my boyfriend, so it's a little different than having kids to feed. We pretty much have the same tastes, though I'm a bit more adventurous than he is. When I went veg 18 months ago he was happy to go along with it, even though he still eats meat occasionally when we go out.
My mum has a saying about picky eaters- apparently, they're just "great cooks in the making". It has definitely proven true for my sister and me. I was super picky as a kid (still am in a way), but now I've just channelled all that attention to taste and texture into cooking! My sister is the same way, though she's more of a baker than a cook.
Though, like some of you, I definitely tend to overeat because of this. I'm trying to loose about 4 pounds and it's very tough going- I am very bad at "listening to my body", to know how much/when to feed it. I just love food so much, I'd eat it all if I could!