Another item on my list is a checked/gingham button down like the one Aida wore, or this one (though it's more than twice my ideal price range!):

http://shop.nordstrom.com/s/c-.....n=wishlist

There are a couple on the Madewell site, but between their dicey size chart and their final sale/no returns or exchange policy, I'm hesitant to try them. Does anyone have any feedback on them? They're run by j. crew, right/? The site and irritating return policies seem similar...