Keep! I love them. Very true to your style. I think try the other color too.

No, I didn't get any boots this winter. They were a want not a need. And to be honest our winter has been quite mild, we were away for 6 weeks when all the worst weather happened and since we got home its been more like spring. I've hardly worn any of my other ankle boots ....

Keep for sure if they are comfy IMO.

I vote BOTH - but I am a terrible enabler... These are terrific, in my opinion! I also love the detail of the shape of your top from the side view. I love how your outfits, while simple and strong, also have amazing detail that makes them special and unique. I think these boots would be a wonderful addition to that!

What an excellent fit! And I see no stumps. I vote keep.

If you really like the brown ones, why not buy them and try to style them with some outfits? If they don't work out, you can always take them back.

Definitely keepers. They look great on you. I'm not as fond of the camel ones; they don't look as pretty, at least in the photo. The leather doesn't look as lustrous as the black.

Thanks so much every one. I'm keeping the black boots and have given the box to master 11 (he loves it when I buy boots, cos you get big boxes). I am drawn to the camel simply because I love the colour and the boot style, but I think it is really a matter of liking it but I probably wouldn't wear it. It's that whole thing of discerning between what you simply like, and what you like for your own wardrobe:). Thanks for talking sense to me xxx

My son loves the boxes too!! If I didn't sneak into his room and pull out boxes when he isn't looking, his room would look like an episode of hoarders!

Ha ha! Sarah mine too:).