Hi Brianna, good to know there is a fellow denim hunter out there... and it sounds like we have some similar requirements.
Note that I used to wear DKNY Sohos, and I like the overall fit initially, BUT they stretch terribly and I do not recommend them!
Here is an update on my own denim quest and the brands I tried:
- David Kahn, original boot cut: the best for me so far. Love the fit everywhere except that I wish the front rise was just a bit higher. I have them at home right now with the tag on and will decide next week whether they are a keeper or not.
- CoH Amber: loved the fit around the butt and legs, but found the front rise a too low (muffin top issue); it's a little lower than the David Kahn's (not by much, but it makes a slight difference and makes me consider the DK, while I returned the Ambers)
- Joe Muse: the rise was okay but I didn't like the fit so much, I thought they flattened my butt
- CoH Kelly: the rise was way too low, these weren't a good candidate
- Rich and Skinny highwaist: loved the high front rise. Not sure about the overall fit; they seem to run small and 29 (which fit alright in the other brands) created a serious "stuffed sausage" effect, yikes. I might try them in 30. However, I also hated the screaming logo on the leg and am not sure I can get past that.
I have not been able to locate the CoH Elson in my size yet (looked at Nordstrom online and in-store, Shopbop and Bluefly) but will probably keep trying, and I also want to try the R&S in a bigger size.
Keep me updated on your progress; I'll definitely watch ths thread to see if there are additional recommendations for my own quest as well.