Feedback on 2 more tops and skirts please

I would love some more feedback on a couple of skirts and tops I bought today. I only want to keep them if they are truly outstanding. I'd love your feedback. By the way, I'm still wearing the shoes that I'm not sure are too sporty or good enough for business so you can see them in context.

1. Yellow top - is this a keeper? And how do the skirts look? Doesn't have to be these combos, I can also wear the top with pants. Also, will of course wear a cami when I'm not so rushed

http://cid-5333dbd44da303c0.sk.....0skirt.jpg

http://cid-5333dbd44da303c0.sk.....jacket.jpg

http://cid-5333dbd44da303c0.sk.....20vest.jpg

2. This top - again doesn't have to be with the skirts. I feel a bit funny about the tie in the middle though it looks obvious that there are belt loops if I remove the tie. Also the tie connects to the detail on the sleeves. Is the collar/top too boxy/square-ish for me?

http://cid-5333dbd44da303c0.sk.....0skirt.jpg

http://cid-5333dbd44da303c0.sk.....0shoes.jpg

Thanks so much!

16 years ago

LoP

Veteran

Hi Sihaya! I love the yellow top and yellow patterned skirt.

The black and white skirt is nice to, but maybe with something else.

I like the white top, but I'm partial to it exactly because of the reasons you listed. It looks 90% good, but maybe not the best. It is how you feel in it that makes it up for the 10% most of the time.

All the other pieces you're wearing is very pretty! I felt like saying it even though you haven't asked.

Danja

(website)

Active Member

Love the skirts, the patterns are really nice. The yellow top is nice, but I would wear it tucked into the skirts. That way it shows more of your line. The vest is very nice too, but I would wear it with something else, like pants or jeans or not so silky skirt. The little jacket is very cute, but I am not sure whether it goes with the rest of the outfit. Perhaps if the top was clingy it would look better. And finally, I am not feeling the white shirt, the black details are a little bit distracting. Hopes this helps.

Anonymous

I really love the white blouse and the yellow skirt you are wearing together. That makes a great summertime outfit, so pretty.
The yellow top is beautiful but I think there is too much yellow going on in the outfit with the yellow top and skirt. I would love to see that top with jeans.

You look wonderful in yellow! I really like the skirts, yellow top and vest on you. I have reservations about the white top with black and the jacket. The white top is cute but the black line really stands out as a strong horizontal that's widening because it extends to your arms, if that makes sense. The jacket is probably fine. Something seems off in the proportions in the way you are wearing it. It seems a bit like a trapeze jacket that needs a more fitted layer under it.

Patience

I think everything is great. I really love both skirts and I think the yellow top works with them colorwise, but is too long for skirts. How do you feel about tucking? The jacket is awesome and I think that outfit would be delish with the blouse tucked. I don't mind the belt on the white blouse, but maybe you would like it more if you substituted a regular non ribbon belt? I could see that working really well.

Oh how I love yellow and grey.

marianne

Wow, that black/white/yellow skirt is fantastic! Love the yellow top, and especially the grey/yellow combination, the grey color is so beautiful. Maybe aside from the tucking you could try belting it?
I like the white shirt, too and don't see an issue with the belt. And I have to say it again, the color scheme looks amazing with your coloring.

Evelina

I think the skirts would look more wonderful just a a tad shorter.

Angie

Fashion Stylist

Oooh la la! Someone went shopping. Fun :0)

I think the skirts will look fab a little shorter. Great styles!

The yellow top is best with the grey jacket layered over it, imo. That’s a KILLER outfit, Sihaya.

The white top is lovely. Great for the body you are in. Good scores!

Dani

My favorite is the yellow top with the grey jacket and the yellow patterned skirt. I clicked on that picture and said "that's an outfit!". Great combo. Btw...we are shoe twins. I have the grey Ecco ballet flats as well...aren't they great?!? What brand are your red ballet flats (you know how much I love red shoes *grin*)?

Sihaya

Thanks everyone for your feedback. This is super helpful. I will have the skirts shortened. Dani - the red ballet flats are also ECCO, exact same style, just in red patent. It's a great color and texture. So is their black patent which has navy undertones. I almost bought that one too.

Category