I like the first one plus you have written far more pros for that dress x

This is a lot of fun - the voting. Dress DeathMatch - fun!

I *love* the NAS dress. It's way, way better than the Marshall's one.

What's next? Skirt Showdown?

:)

I prefer the first one. Don't keep both because they are so similar..

I also vote to keep the first one, I strongly prefer it to the second one and the color is gorgeous.

Another vote for the first one.

Again, I hope you keep the NAS dress -- to my eyes, the length is more flattering.

The fit of the NAS dress is much better than the other dress. I also like the length of the NAS dress much better.

Another vote for the first one.It looks really fantastic and it is SO difficult to find a dress in that color. Keep!

Again I'm voting for the first one, I much prefer the length of this dress.

I'm voting #1, too!

Yowza, this one is not close at all! Good to know there are clearer heads prevailing instead of just mine. :)

The comments about the length of the second one are eye-opening; thank you, I would not have caught that, but it's a great point!

Okay, the Marshalls one for sure will be returned; I am sure I will find a different edgy dress in a different style eventually.

And I was keeping the NAS one no matter what the voting said. :P

Another NAS vote....seems this one is unanimous!!!