OR

What To Wear on a Date

I haven’t been on a date date in a very long time. So I have no recent first hand experience with dating and date-appropriate outfits. Of course, Greg and I do have date night and in that case I’ll wear something that he especially likes, which means NO ruffles or extra shiny fabrications.

I do have a lot of recent second hand experience with dating outfits though. I have many single clients, at many different stages of life, that request my help with date-appropriate attire. We often end up building “a date wear capsule”, which also includes daywear options because a date can mean a mid morning cup of coffee, an early afternoon stroll, or a ball game.

I suggest to my clients that above all else, they should choose a dating outfit that makes them feel comfortable and confident. For some this means jeans, blouse and boots. For others it means a casual dress, denim jacket or cardigan. Or it can mean a skirt and top, trousers and sweater, jacket and short shorts, or sheath and heels.

Being comfortable also has to do with how you relate to your context. In other words, your outfit should be appropriate for the occasion on the casual/formal scale. You might not be comfortable wearing a cocktail dress when everyone else is in jeans, and vice versa.

So the basics are all about you being relaxed in your outfit: How you feel wearing it and how it fits the occasion. Seems simple enough. But my experience with clients tells me this is easier said than done. There are two deeper questions that almost always come up.

The first question is around the extent to which you are going to reflect your normal fashion persona. Personally, I fall into the “just be yourself” camp. If you are a dramatic, trendy and flamboyant dresser, this should come through in your date wear. If you are a modest, preppy and classic dresser, show off these great looks. Dress romantically if that tickles your fancy. If arty and edgy ensembles are your thing, don’t hide them. It’s best that your date sees the way you normally dress straight off the bat.

Of course, there are also good arguments for playing it safe on date night, tempering your style to avoid preconceived judgements. Perhaps you will stick to neutral colours instead of your normal brights, or forgo the clanking and jiggling jewelry that you normally wear. Maybe you’ll go without your favourite perfume in case your date has allergies. Maybe you’ll wear contact lenses instead of your specs.

The second tricky question concerns the alluring factor. Should you show more skin at date time? Should you wear something form fitting? My advice on this one is, again, to be yourself. If you are a naturally modest dresser, don’t feel the pressure to wear something more tight or revealing. If you feel good showing some more curve and skin, go for it. Keeping in mind the dress code of course.

These are the main questions that I thrash out with my clients. Some want to pull out all the stops and look as alluring and dramatic as possible at date time. Others feel they should reign in their eclectic style and play it safe. There are no right answers that apply universally to all women — ultimately the right thing for you will be the decision that makes you the most comfortable and confident. Then you can relax and have fun.

I would love to hear your point of view on how to dress for a date. Whether you are currently on the dating circuit of not, what are your suggestions for date-appropriate attire?

Comment RSS

42 Comments on...
What To Wear on a Date

One so easily forgets how many “what ifs” one has to contend with on a first date! Eek. Wish I had a ‘date wear capsule’ when I had to dress to impress!

I remember the agonies of had you got it right!
I met DH when I was 18 married at 20 and have had him nailed down since then
( poor soul ) So other than our date nights I am way out of touch with this subject.
As you say Angie I think the only way to go is to be yourself, your best self, but what you are comfortable with. If you try to be somone you are not how is your date going to know you?

I’m from the “just be yourself category”. I think one should dress for confidence with the most figure flattering styles wearing your most skin tone flattering colors near the face (keeping in mind the weather and whats appropriate for the type of date of course). Makeup should be natural and not overdone and hair and nails well groomed. I tend to go towards more form fitting clothes and try to keep proportion in check. Short skirts with less revealing top, revealing top with conservative bottom. Accessories should not be overdone but a unique piece will make you stand out from the ordinary. Lastly, never underestimate a great smile and a pretty natural lip (gloss or color).

This is such great advice! It’s funny, because I’m not dating anymore, but I’m trying to figure out what to wear to my college reunion next weekend– and this applies beautifully. Thank you!

Gosh… my last date was 21 years ago. I have a hard enough time trying to decide what to wear for an evening out with girlfriends.. I can’t imagine a date!
My observations are that men as a rule aren’t impressed with overly done make-up, hair, or uber trendy or fancy clothing… so I’d keep that in mind. Yes, you want to be yourself, but you also don’t want to scare anybody off.
I know I’m going to sound like a total prude here, but to me there is nothing worse than seeing a girl out on an obvious date dressed like she’s ready to work the street corner. The other day I was out with my husband and a young couple walked by.. he was dressed in nice jeans and a button down I think, and she had on a dress that was very tight, very low cut and very short. I remember thinking “Gosh… I hope you’re not trying to impress this guy with your intelligence or sophistication…”

I gave up on dating a couple of years ago, but when I did, I was always fairly casual about dressing. It’s different than if it’s a first date where you don’t really know the person, vs. a date with a partner of longer standing. I’m fairly reserved about letting people into my pants, so I always kept my first-date outfits pretty non-sexy, and paid attention to having freedom of movement. Suede sneakers, cords, a pretty top and a jacket is a pretty common look for me, or if it’s hot, a dress and flats. If I am going with someone I know well to an event that requires more dressing up, that’s a whole different ballgame of course.

I’m also no authority, since I’m approaching my 10 year anniversary. QM, I think you are right about that last part. Any date outfit should be sophisticated, whatever that means to you. I always think about something that is fashion forward, perfectly fitted, feminine, sassy but not trampy.

I’ve been married over 40 years so definitely not dating. However, I enjoy seeing the young people out on dates when we are dining out. Number one on my list would be a happy attitude followed by impeccable grooming. A woman with flattering hairstyle and shiny locks, groomed hands and feet, makeup not overdone..she stands out.
The ones that seem to be going for ” look as alluring and dramatic as possible” can look like they are trying too hard if they don’t get it right.

I am out of the dating loop – but wanted to comment on the thoroughness of this post (which is one of the reasons I love YLF so much, I am also considering stepping up my participation here!)
What I can say about my significant other is that he was not put off by the rather unflattering way I dressed at the time that we met. However, he has since helped me in the past seven years to dress a little more colourfully and embrace the good qualities I have.
I know how hard and unforgiving dating is, and that there are reasons one might to somewhat camouflage at first. But I would definitely say that going *too* far away from who we are will ultimately attract the wrong person (which can be a bit draining).

Angie, I think you have nailed it. Being yourself so you can be comfortable and confident. If you’re dating to have a second date, I think this would be key.

I have not been on the dating circuit in several years (have known BF for 12 years now and been dating him for a large portion of that) but I am firmly in the “be yourself” category. Tone it down if you’re really uncomfortable revealing that much of your style on a first date, but don’t adopt a totally different persona (I know girls who do this, and it drives me nuts). Assuming that you want a second date/relationship, you’re going to have to show your true self sooner or later, and it makes everything easier and potentially less disastrous if you start out honestly! This is the same reason why I don’t get why some women always wear shapewear and/or padded bras when they go on a date – assuming you want the relationship to progress, sooner or later they’re going to have to come off!

Re: showing cleavage/skin. I actually used to pay more attention to dressing modestly when I was going on date rather than just going out with friends/going shopping/whatever, the reason being that I didn’t want to give the wrong impression. Plus I didn’t want the guy thinking only about my boobs! I am by nature pretty shy, introverted, and reserved, but not in my dressing. Which is fine, but I was always a little afraid of what showing too much skin might suggest on a first date.

What I’d want to keep in mind – not having dated in over 30 years – is the thought that if I ended up with this person permanently, would I want to dress this way permanently? If not, I’m not being myself and that’s not fair to either of us.

I actually am on the dating circuit and I like to dress up. For me, its an occasion (excuse?) to dress up, and I like wowing people. xD I don’t mean wearing something super short or anything like that really, more like pulling out that piece that you’ve been hiding at the back of a drawer for a while that makes you look hot and wearing it!

Yikes! I keep turning down date offers because I am not ready to do all of this again (my last non-married “date” was over 12 years ago). Clothing is an important way to express myself so I think I would definitely not be shy about my showing my personal style right off the bat. I would want him to do the same, it is something I really enjoy knowing about people. When I went on my married dates with my husband I would do the same as you Angie, I would wear things that I knew he enjoyed seeing me in. I think that comes with intimacy. I can’t see myself doing that for people I’m just getting to know so (when the day comes) I am sure I will dress for my own personal comfort. Thanks to the YLF archives I will have lots of ideas for pretty much any type of outing!

Lots of good advice above, Myrna’s comment is very good!!!

I have been avoiding dating for the past few years, but I did end up on 1 “started out as just coffee, ended up as a date”. I dread to think what I will wear now if I went on a date; I am now 3 to 4 sizes bigger than I used to be, and I am just starting to put together pieces for my now wardrobe. My older (smaller) standbys won’t necessarily work for me now, including vintage day dresses (I liked pulling those out for a date, a good excuse to dress up). I prefer casual events b/c I like to be casual, but sometimes a more formal event is on the agenda. I need to come up with a “dating capsule” pretty quick: a fairly charming man has payed some attention to me (yes, that’s “fat” me, not skinny me) and I’m starting to like him too. I only run into him on certain occasions, but I on the next occasion, I want to look good, just in case. I’m more conscious about making a good impression now than I used to be (not that before I would necessarily make a negative impression), b/c I see how much impact that has on how people relate to us. I still firmly believe in the “be yourself” motto; no point in false advertising. Doesn’t do you or anybody else any good in the long run.
Will be needing LOTS of help on the forum hopefully soon.

As someone who has been actively dating the last 2 1/2 years, I still agonize over what to wear to each date. I definitely tone down how I dress. I keep my make-up pretty simple and low key as well.
I don’t want to be perceived as too high maintenance or unwillingly to go do unglamourous stuff.
Right now I’m taking a break from dating.

Since the whole point of dating is to find someone who likes you, I think the most important thing is to dress like yourself. It’s possible that the other person might have some preconceptions about people with certain elements of your style, but I personally would not want to date someone who thought of anything that’s important to me that way.

Beyond that, I always just tried to dress how I normally would for the occasion and place. Usually I would make a bit more effort with my makeup. It has been a while since I’ve done the whole dating thing; I’ve been married for almost three years, and we lived together for the two and a half before that.

What an interesting post and intriguing comments. I haven’t dated in 20 years, and even before that never really experienced the heightened date pressures that seem to exist in the US (I lived in Germany before meeting my current partner, and the concept of dating is a little less “heavy” there, I find, in terms of not being quite as expectation-laden and stress-inducing as here.) So I don’t really have personal experience to attribute. But if I imagined myself dating now, Angie’s advice of being true to yourself would definitely resonate with me. I like to dress a little bit funky and, when going out, a little dramatic at times, and I imagine I would do so on a first date, because that really is “me” and I wouldn’t want to pretend to be different or “less” than I am. I imagine, though, that I’d avoid any outfits that are more experimental, present more of a fashion risk for me. So bold, yes, but experimental, no. Does that make sense?

I only remember 3 or 4 ‘real’ dates in my life and I can pretty much remember what I wore on each one! A skirt and fun top 3 times and a column maxi dress with matching crop jacket/shirt once. The skirts were to a) go dancing b) casual bite at a mexican place and c) a Heavenly Ski company Christmas party. The dress was for David Copperfield at Caeasars. I do recall borrowing a jacket from a friend for the company party that was a bit too tight in the waist and although I looked cute, after 3 or 4 hours, having your midriff squeezed is no fun! I felt appropriately dressed in each situation but as I said, the comfort factor was an issue in the tight jacket . . .

I am actually not entirely on Team Be Yourself. Obviously it doesn’t pay to pretend to be a completely different person, or dress in a way that makes you uncomfortable, but you’re not going to be revealing everything about yourself on the first date anyway…why should your clothes? Well, I guess I’m just making assumptions that might not be true for everyone, but I know I am not terribly forthcoming on first dates (or even in general)>

In my experience as a straight gal, most men don’t particularly care about clothes, but do care about a pretty face and hair. The only consideration I have with clothes is how modest they are. For me it is very important not to dress in a revealing way because I don’t want there to be any question about my intentions.

Generally, I would sooner focus my energy on grooming than clothes.

My husband and I have been married for 19 years and he still talks about my first date outfit and how amazing I was in it. It was a white t-shirt, faded fabulous fitting jeans, and a black blazer!

I am married to my second husband and had a period of frequent and furious dating in between husbands. :) I agree, you should dress like yourself for a date. I also think you should be really thoughtful about how much skin you show. I don’t think you should dress like a nun, but it’s natural for guys to get the wrong idea when a woman is showing a lot of cleavage or leg.

Clothes send a message and never more than on a first date. Here’s one of my date night uniforms: premium boot cuts, heels, and a sleeveless cowl neck top with either a cardi or knit jacket with scrunchable sleeves. Add a clutch and some dangly earrings, and I think you can go just about anywhere!

Is there a “how to get a date” segment to this, Angie? :P

Wow, this is one of the most interesting questions you’ve asked. I’m going to agree with you, Angie, that on a date you should dress in a way that represents who you are, because I think it helps you look and act natural — and that’s the goal of a date, right? To show the guy what a great person you actually are!

You might want to make a little more effort to look well turned-out (and this is true for men as well as women), but go with what is “you.” So, for example, if your “normal” includes dramatic makeup and monster stiletto heels, then it would make sense to go with that. For me, dramatic makeup and super-high heels is a bit out of character. I do wear them sometimes, but since it’s not typical for me, so I wouldn’t do it for a date (especially not a first date).

For me, too, it has been a very long time since I’ve been on a DATE date — i.e. with a man I’m just getting to know. I’ve been with my husband since I was 22. But before him, I went on my fair share of dates, and back then I did have a very clear idea of how I should dress for them. My golden rule was to NOT LOOK LIKE YOU’RE TRYING TOO HARD! I wanted to look attractive, naturally, but I didn’t want to LOOK like I was trying to look attractive, if you know what I mean. I wanted the guy to see me as I actually was — nothing more, nothing less. So I dressed exactly as I would normally dress, which at the time was pretty casual, but I chose garments that were my particular favourites and that I knew were flattering. So, for example, I’d wear broken-in but flattering jeans, and a top which wasn’t low-cut, but clung in the right places. I always left my thick shiny hair down, because lots of guys love that. I didn’t wear heels often back then, and I certainly would not have done so on a date (especially a first date), because in my mind that would have looked like “too much.” I also paid extra attention to applying my makeup, but made sure it didn’t look like I had a lot on, because I was pretty sure guys did not dig high-maintenance girls.

If I were thrown into the dating pool now, as a 30-something, my “dressing for a date” rules would be a little different. I wouldn’t worry so much about not looking like I’m trying too hard. I still definitely wouldn’t dress in a way that is out of character, but the actual clothing I’d choose would be quite different, because my style has changed and evolved over the years. I would wear (reasonable) heels, and I would wear a skirt/dress, and I would look a little more polished than I did in my 20s!
Personally, I’d stay away from anything TOO sexy or revealing, but looking subtly sexy is nice. A pencil skirt with nice heels and a button-down blouse is perhaps what I would wear if I were going on a date with a stranger tomorrow. But the bottom line is still to look and feel natural, because ultimately you want to ACT normal too, and that’s hard to do when you’re wearing something you’re not comfortable in!

A dating capsule is a great idea. We all make quick first impressions whether on a date or in a business meeting.

I haven’t gone on a first date for almost a dozen years, but when I was dating I was very ‘like it or lump it’. So I dressed very ME and didn’t tone down. Though that was back before online dating was popular, so if I was going out with someone, he already knew how I dressed so changing my look was unnecessary. The only restrictions were on being appropriate for whatever the date entailed.

Now, when my guy and I go on dates – I dress with the end of the evening in mind, so it’s usually something that’s going to knock his socks off.

When I was dating, I wore what I felt comfortable in and what I thought would suit the event we were doing. I’m a big fan of jeans so that was the constant piece of my look. Heels in warmer months, or boots in cooler months. The top depended on the event, casual: t-shirt, a nicer evening-a button down shirt (I did not wear blouses prior to YLF). If I went on a date now, I may swap in a dress here or there to vary up my look more (since I now wear more dresses) and swap out a t-shirt for a blouse but my big effort on a date would still be the same, a focus on my footwear. Heels just made me feel sexy and powerful, two attributes I always wanted to have on a date.

I really like what you have to say here. I think I lean more towards being yourself. For me that is showing off my hourglass silhouette with a hint of glitz. The activity really does dictate what I would wear (like you, I have been off the market for a number of years). Jeans and a cute flattering T-shirt is perfect for a ball game if that’s what it calls for. I guess dinner could be trickier…..it would depend on the restaurant. I have always wanted to wear a sexy sheath dress out to a fancy restaurant on a date like they do in the movies!!! However in real life, the restaurants we normally select have a more relaxed vibe. I think I take this approach to most situations I encounter…dress as how you are. I will say the first few dates with my husband….I did go the “extra” mile. Perhaps it paid off!

I like what Maya said. I think there’s a lot to be said for a little bit of editing until you feel comfortable with the other person.

Good question, Angie. I think I would try to stick true to my style persona, dress to be both mentally and physically comfortable, and dress for the occasion. But the first point is hard for me because I’m a moody dresser in general. And it’s hard to pick sometimes. Also, it’s not my personality to pull out all the stops, wear dramatic makeup, and dress in a super alluring (conventionally sexy) way.

It disappoints me that a lot of men I know (straight, different ages) are not interested nor seem to get some fashion. The ones who are more astute tend to prefer the modern classic look, which is perfectly fine, but doesn’t always mesh with what I fee like doing.

Hmmm, I find it telling that most of the commenters are NOT currently dating.

As always, your comments are so insightful. Thank you!

Maya and Sammi, I like your comments about taking grooming extra seriously on date night.

Elisaberh, your thought process is great.

Queen Mum, not “scaring one off” on date night is a hard one, don’t you think? When do you actually begin dressing like yourself when you have a dramatic style? I hear you too. It’s tricky!

Antje, your reasoning makes perfect sense.

Lena, mood dressing might be just the right ingredient for date nights :)

What a great post! I have also been out of the dating world for a long time, but oh how I remember agonizing over what to wear on a date.

If only I could go back in time and follow your advice–just be myself. :)

The last time I was “dating” was around the time I discovered YouLookFab, and my personal style wasn’t quite there yet. On my first date with my current boyfriend – a casual meetup at a coffee place – I wore simple pumps, bootcut jeans, an emerald-colored V-neck sweater, and a pretty necklace. Just simple and clean. I think Bryan prefers it when I am wearing simpler outfits in general, but I also wouldn’t have worn the outfit if it didn’t feel like “me” at the time.

I think this is an issue which is so easy to over think. When my Sister recently asked for advice I told her to think of what she would wear if she happened to be meeting her best friend instead of her date. I really can’t argue with Angie’s ‘be yourself’ mantra.

On my first date with my boyfriend of almost 2 years I wore jeans, a black shirt with a little sparkle around the collar, a black light sleeveless cardigan, and some high heeled boots.

I live in jeans, and we went to see a movie at night, so this outfit made sense to me. I wasn’t showing any skin, but I’m modest in general. I had on light make up, and wore my hair down. He actually hadn’t seen my hair down since we’d met and hung out all day at an event 3 days in a row, so it seemed like a good idea.

I still pay more attention to dressing cute when I see him, but he’s seen my jeans and t-shirt days too, so I’m very comfortable with wearing whatever I want to now. Being yourself is a great way to go, but still pay attention to how you look so your date knows that you care. Confidence and a smile are the most attractive things you can wear. For me this means no stiletto heels, no matter how cute they are.

great question, lots of excellent advice in the post and the comments! the idea of a date capsule is genius. i’ve been married 11 years, but this is my 1st marriage which occurred when i was 37 – so i have plenty of dating experience.

to me, the purpose of a first date is to see if you like the guy enough for a second date, and to GET that second date if you want it! so i would dress as my self but with two additional considerations: i wouldn’t go with my most outlandishly out-there looks (which even my family finds perplexing at times) and i would make sure to be dressed appropriately for the event/context. I’ve found first dates are nerve-wracking enough without being the ‘black sheep’, and in my opinion dressing appropriately always shows a respect for the people around you, which is important to me. a couple of other posters have advised against putting on an entirely different persona and i really second that advice! for me i just don’t like to go to my most ‘intellectually demanding’ looks on a first date.

i’ve dated in urban areas, so i make sure my footwear can take plenty of walking, no matter if no walking is stated in the itinerary (go with Angie’s ‘Eight Hour Shoes’ :) you never know when your date will suggest a romantic walk through Little Italy in the moonlight, rather than taking a cab. 4″ stilettos are bad enough on a gal’s feet, but on the San Francisco hills? Yikes!

Best wishes to all the dating ladies out there – whatever doesn’t kill you makes you stronger, right!?!? ;) have fun, steph

Mercifully, I have not been on a “date” in 23 years (long marriage, followed by relationship with SO, whom I had already known for a while when we got together romantically.)

I know, however, that if I were dating, I would definitely agonize over what to wear. And I would drag the YLF community into that agony, so you should all be as grateful as I am that I am not going on dates. ;)

Great practical advice, as always. I am going to share this post with my daughter. So glad that I don’t have to navigate the dating scene. It’s been 37 years since my first date with hubby, and the details have long since faded into history.

I loved this post. It’s always worth dressing up – whatever that means for you — to celebrate a date whether with a new person, partner or spouse. Although Seattle men are definitely more casual, I’m guessing they feel flattered and honored when a date dresses up (even if they aren’t). It’s a lovely way to both celebrate beauty and human connection.

Eve Tai, La Modette
http://www.seattlealamode.com)

My strange advice is to not dress up on a FIRST date — at all. No heels, earrings, no lipstick, eyeshadow, etc. unless you can truly make these items look casual. The idea is to look nice in a way that says, “I don’t try to impress men I don’t know and you haven’t given me a reason to. Yet.”

In my experience, men often dress casually on a first date, as a signal — consciously or not — and they read how women dress as a signal of how much effort she is willing to put forth to impress ANY guy — not them in particular.

If/when I do dress up later, they can take it as a sign they’ve earned it and then they seem to enjoy it greatly.

Leave a Comment


OR