OR

The polka dot preference

You’ll find polka dot printed items in stores every season. But because polka dots are trending strongly this Spring, you’ll probably see more spotted items than usual. I’m not complaining! Polka dots are my all time favourite pattern. I love the simple, geometric simplicity of this shape that spells playful fun.

That being said, I choose my polka dot items carefully. The design of the polka dot has to be just right and so does the item that bears it. I might be in the minority, but I don’t think everything looks good in a polka dot.

Design of the dot

Three things are important: color, size and spacing.

  1. Color: I usually prefer a white or cream dot against a solid background colour. I also like light backgrounds with dark dots, but I normally don’t go for multi-coloured polka dot designs (more than two colours) unless the palette is extremely monochromatic.
  2. Size: Small dots are subtle while large dots are bold (especially if there is a high contrast between the colour of the dot and the colour of the background). Both options tickle my toes. Then there is the uniformity of the size. I quite like designs with differently sized polka dots but much prefer the cleaner look of uniformly sized dots.
  3. Spacing: I prefer evenly spaced dots, especially on designs where they are uniformly sized.

If you prefer a subtle look, opt for a single coloured pin dot sized polka dot on a solid colour, like a small white dot on a black background.

Style of the item

I’ve seen a polka dot on just about every wardrobe item, including accessories, but some items are more surprising than others, and are therefore more of a statement. Of course, the risk goes up proportionately with the surprise factor.

  1. Mainstream: Tops, shirts, blouses and scarves are easy items to add to the wardrobe in polka dot designs.
  2. Occasional: Dresses, skirts, socks, headbands, umbrellas, underwear, sleepwear, bathing costumes, hose, ties and floral pins are next. The sheer surface area of dresses and skirts makes them less mainstream in a bold pattern than the items above. The others aren’t common in polka dots, but they are small or hidden, and therefore less of a dotty statement than the items below.
  3. Unusual: Pants, walk shorts, coats, jackets and knitwear are harder to get right. Somehow these items are more likely to appear clownish. Bags, belts and shoes are also less popular in polka dot patterns.

I have several polka dot dresses, blouses, scarves and umbrellas, and one spotty floral pin. These are the items I like best in clean graphic polka dot designs. I’d love to find a polka dot skirt, belt and pair of pumps one day, but that’s it. I probably won’t sport a polka dot on any other wardrobe item.

Over to you. Do you like polka dots? If so, what’s your favourite design? Which wardrobe items will you sport in that design?

Comment RSS

45 Comments on...
The polka dot preference

You’ve given me a wanting for a chiffony white and black polka dot scarf- I’m off to trawl Ebay!!!

I’ve never been much of a polka dot person, but I have a new polka dot and floral skirt that I love. The dots are large but subtle (light grey on white and charcoal on black). I definitely prefer evenly spaced uniformly sized dots to random.

Love polka dots, although I dearly love my stripes too. One thing I don’t own is a polka dot blouse. Should you happen to come across any that work for apples, please add them to the store!!!! xx

I have two polka dot pieces in my wardrobe. I have a jersey blazer which is a butter yellow colour with a yolk orange small scale polka dot (I know it has to be seen to be appreciated) and a scarf which is cherry red with a small white polka dot. Neither of these pieces are worn much as I much prefer stripes but I do have a soft spot for the polka dot bags of the Cath Kidston website.

I love dots! I have a short wool skirt that is cream with black dots, a pink swimsuit with small white dots, a polka dot blouse, a polka dot dress, and a scarf with lime green dots. Most of my polka dots are black and white. I would love a summery skirt with dots, but I have to find the right one.

I’d love more dots…

I have been thinking of getting some Cath Kidston vintage green polka dot sneakers, but am starting to wonder now…

I like dots. It´s not easy to outbalance the very girly appearance with an edge. You really have to pick the items carefully.
How can one integrate polka dots into business wear?

Love ‘em. I’ve been stocking up for months in all sizes of dot!

Uh oh, sorry Angie, but the polkadot dress I am eyeing is multi-color. Like you, I’m usually drawn to black or white on a solid background, but this one is just calling my name. I’m reading these more as personal preferences than “rules” though because I think I know you well enough to guess that you would absolutely approve of the dress I’m after (though I know you would not wear it yourself)!

I’m also going to have to agree to disagree on polkadot coats. I’d totally wear one and not worry about clownishness.

http://www.betseyjohnson.com/s.....uctid=6843

I adore polkas but my polka wardrobe is sorely lacking. A polkadot skirt, dress, and blouse are all on my wish list.

I”d love to find a pair of polka dot tights JUST KIDDING :-)
I love my polka dot blouse and am not really in the market for anything else, but if I happen to stumble across something I can’t live without then I’d grab it. I think given my age and style, I need to stick with simple polka dot patterns.

Neither, in that I have small amounts of both, but really no preference. I am currently in lust with this dress though – http://www.asos.com/Karen-Mill.....8;clr=Blue

Karen Millen has such an amazing range this season!

I do adore polka dots, and I would love to have a polka dotted jacket for spring!

OMG, that Karen Millen dress is GORGEOUS! I want it…

I have them on dresses but not accessories. I might get me a polka dot umbrella now.

I have polka dot shirts, scarves, and dresses. Yes – multiples of each, except the scarves. I actually just picked up two polka-dot dresses at my favorite thrift store a few weeks ago. One of them is red and white and looks sort of ’40s, which I love.

I love polka dots. =o)

Also a fan of the polka dot. I am glad that the fashion world has officially given them their blessing in a big way as I’ll admit to being a bit shy/insecure about wearing them before.

I have a couple of blouses, skirts and dresses in various states of polka-dot-ness.

I even have cream colored, floor to ceiling curtain sheers with polka dots (Thomas O’Brien Vintage Moderns for Target) in a bedroom.

I loveee polka dots. I am fiercely searching for a polka dot pencil skirt but so far have not had any luck. It would be the perfect addition to my wardrobe!

Currently I have a couple polka dot blouses, a polka dot dress, and a wool cropped jacket I just thrifted… I don’t think it looks clownish at all, but I’ll post it on the forum to get my clown rating. :) I recently tried on a polka dot trench coat and it was adorable. I agree with Maya that polka dot coats can look absolutely sophisticated if done correctly!

I still mourn the loss of my favorite Ann Taylor sweater set which was light blue with brown polka dots. I literally had to retire it due to wear. It’s hard to describe, but the dots were small and the effect was interesting but still fairly classic.

Currently, I the only polka dotted item I own is a blue silk shirt with white dots. It’s pretty and fun for spring and summer. I also occasionally steal my daughter’s multicolored pollka dot rain boots.

I am a big fan of white even sized dots on a dark brown background. Maya picked that exact pattern for her coat. Yummy!

I too prefer darker backgrounds for the high contrast dots, but do like the lighter background with low contrast dots. Dusty’s white skirt with light grey dots sounds perfect.

Unlike Angie, I do not care for the really tiny dots. I also prefer the dots on my skirt or in my frock, rather than my top. Accessories like scarves, socks, and umbrellas are great too.

I have always felt that white half inch dots on a navy blue background are very sophisticated.
I have recently bought my first dotted blouse and a scarf, both white dots on navy blue, or black, it’s hard to tell sometimes.
I just never found the piece to buy in the past. I’m so glad many dotted items are being offered right now.

So I for one have to say that I like polka dots fine, but am not a polka dot lover. I own a few items:
- a small scarf with cream dots on black; I use it as part of business outfits (neatly tucked under a jacket) to bring in just a little of spunk
- red tights with fuchsia dots – those are very fun and I wear them lots, with a denim skirt or short black skirt, for a fun and casual look
- a halter dress with white dots on black. I wear it about once/year and always feel just a little teensy bit costumey in it, not my favorite.

I sometimes try polka dot blouses but somehow always feel just a tad too “cute” in them. I’m sure it’s just my own lack of imagination; Angie’s style can certainly not be called “cute” and polka dot looks super stylish on her. But somehow I can’t really pull it off, and so I’m not going to go on a hunt for more dots.

I love polka dots but like many others, I don’t really wear them. I am also scared to be too cutesy. I’m looking forward to what comes out in stores!

LOVE polka dots. Last year i added a very full black and white polka dot trench to my spring wardrobe. This coat gets compliments everywhere I go!

I also have black and white polka dot wrap shirt that I bought this season (wearing it today!), as well as a black and white halter dress that I bought many summers ago.

I like medium sized or small polka dots. Mine are all white on a black background.
I agree, I don’t think they go out of style. Polka dots and geometric prints are my favorite patterns.

I am ususally a solids kinda girl , but I love white or cream polka dots on a black background only. I have a polka dot dress and a skirt , also 2 blouses…I am looking for a scarf:)

I’m with Antje in that I’m not a major polka-dot lover. I occasionally wear them, but not very often and never in bright colors. Here’s my theory on why I’m not drawn to them: I believe my personal “clown factor” is greatly ramped up by my curly hair, and anything that even hints at clownish puts it over the top. (Those of you who met me in NYC — that was as smooth and tamed as my hair ever is. Trust me, when the humidity rises, it acquires serious clown potential.)

IMHO, some things go better with sleeker, sharper, more modern hairstyles. If your hair is a little wilder, it’s harder to pull off certain looks.

I love, love polka dots and that Karen Millen dress is amaaaazing!

Oddly enough, I don’t think I have anything dotty right now. Must rectify that situation immediately :O

I like but don’t love polka dots. My favourite is white dots on navy blue. I prefer polka dots on little girls: sun-dresses and the like.

I have a black silk chiffon button-down with white polka dots (and 3/4 length sleeves) that is one of my favourite tops. I haven’t seen much dot action here (Sydney) but will be looking out for it!

Love polka dots. Love the look. Love the name. Who can forget Pretty Woman Julia Roberts at the horse races in that brown and white polka dot dress?

You’re absolutely right that not all polka-dot patterns are equally appealing. I like a pale smallish dot on a dark solid background best. Red, navy, and black backgrounds usually look best to me. I prefer my polka-dots on fitted, feminine blouses, slightly retro dresses, or umbrellas.

Like Malcontent, I have a slight preference for polka dots on retro shaped dresses and blouses. But really, I’m very glad there’s more choice right now. Bring them on!

I passed on a polka dot scarf last year because the dots were too small for my taste.

I also prefer dots that are unevenly spaced.

Polka dots seem like a breath of fresh air. At the moment I only have them represented in my closet as scarves…all white/cream uniform dots from pin point to quarter-sized on backgrounds of black, ink and red. (This seems confusing when I reread it. I have several different polka dot scarves in different shapes and sizes and colors).
If on a larger item, I’d want the dots fairly small. I’ll probably continue to limit my polka dots to scarves or maybe a knit tank type cami at most. There are dresses that look so cute on the hanger that look clownish or overwhelming on my body.

I don’t have any polka dot clothing at the moment, but I did just buy a couple of polka dot floral pins at Kohl’s. I couldn’t decide between the black with white polka dots or the white with black polka dots, so I got both! With a price tag of $5.00 I thought that was ok, don’t you?

KristenKP and I are polka dot scarf twins, having each picked up a berry red colored scarf with white polka dots at Zara this weekend. Love the dots!

I like polka dots, too. Unfortunately, I haven’t seen too many here yet. One of my favorite outfits ever was a pair of royal blue, rayon pants with white polka dots and a royal blue and white rugby striped cotton sweater. (I know…it was the eighties and I worked for the Gap!) I also had some polka dot shoes that were super cute. Thanks for the inspiration, Angie. I will have to put out more polka dot radar when I shop.

There are two things I have always disliked in clothing because they are so traditionally girly:
The color pink
Polka dots

I’ve started to not mind some pinks, but the polka dots are still a “No way!” for me. I’ve sworn to never buy anything with dots and I don’t think I’ll change my mind any time soon. You can keep them all for yourself. :)

Now if paisley got popular again… I like paisley.

Me, too love polkas, especially on summer dresses. I have
-one dress chock brown background and tini white dots all over
-one another with cream background and 1cm chock brown dots all over
-one linen dress (M&S) off white with 1cm grey, slate blue, and black dots all over
-one another M&S linen dress with the same off white ground and grey, slate blue, beige 0,5cm dots, which are arranged to make some small circular pattern all over it
-and one which has black background and has white tinnies all over.
Is that too much?:-) All dresses are simple bias or A line cuts, nothing ruffled or so…

Although, I do not own any other clothing piece with polka dots! I think will look too girly (on me)if it’s a skirt, or blouse, or anything else than a dress…don’t now why? But, last spring I bought a polka dotted spring jacket(Kenvelo) to my DD(12yrs) and is her favourite piece. (turned out it’s not girly at all: white background with tini beige dots all over)

I have a sheer navy blouse with a ruffled front, puffed short sleeves and tiny white polka dots. I love it very, very much.

I love polka dots! I own a couple of polka dot items: a jersey dress, knitted top, scarf and floral pin; and curiously, they are all black with white dots. I would love to ass some woven items to my collection: like a blouse, skirt or dress; maybe in the opposite color pattern. I am salivating over this blouse:

http://www.jcrew.com/AST/Brows...../24733.jsp

I have always been a dot-loving gal. I have several skirts, a couple sweaters, and a summer dress (on the verge of wearing out because I wear it so much) that are all dotted. I don’t wear them all together, though–one at a time is just fine. In general, I like mono-colored dots on an off-white background. That said, I am in LOVE with these two scarves:

http://www.pedshoes.com/mia_zi.....lorID=1798

http://www.pedshoes.com/sophie.....lorID=1810

I might splurge big and get one of them (birthday is coming up), but which one? Any thoughts?

I agree with all the ways you like polka dots. I am a fan but stick to only black and with dots or cream and black. I have a black and white polka clutch and have carried it once. I never feel a time to carry it ever. :) Guess it wasn’t a good purchase. :(

I love love love love dots! I only have dots that are <1 cm in diameter though. Maybe I'll try bigger dots one day … eventually ;)

I have a silk wrap blouse that is navy with cream polka dots. That’s the only polka dot garment I own, but I love it.

i think i am a dot lover… i recently decided to buy some scarves that are my style since the scarf look is one i have loved for years but always felt a bit awkward in my mothers handed down scarves. of my 12 recent purchases 5 are various polka dots… the others are geometrics. curiously of all the florals i looked at not a single one came home with me, there is a style revelation i never would have expected!

I love both, however it depends on the item. More structured items (button downshirts, blazers) I prefer in stripes. I like polka dots on blouses, sweaters and flowy skirts. Stripes make me feel bold, polka dots make me feel feminine. How can I choose one over the other? Impossible!!

Leave a Comment


OR